Comparison with Alternatives
Three projects solve the same problem: getting content from German-language public broadcaster Mediatheken into Sonarr and Radarr. All three query the MediathekViewWeb API as their data source and expose a Newznab indexer API and a SABnzbd download client API so the *arr apps treat them like any other Usenet source.
Same Data Source
All three projects query the same MediathekViewWeb API. The available content (ARD, ZDF, ORF, SRF, etc.) is identical - the difference lies in how each project matches, scores and downloads it.
Quick Comparison
| FunkArr | MediathekArr | RundfunkArr | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stack | .NET 10 / Akka.NET | .NET (C#) | Node.js / Next.js |
| Status | Active | Beta (last release Feb 2025) | Active (v1.3.0) |
| GitHub Stars | New project | ~374 | ~40 |
| Sonarr | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Radarr | Yes | Limited (WIP) | Yes (since v1.1.0) |
| Rulesets | Community (auto-synced from GitHub) + custom, web UI editor with live preview | Built-in matching | Community rulesets, auto-update from GitHub |
| Metadata | TMDB + TVDB (requires API keys) | TVDB only | Local shows.json → TVDB → TMDB |
| Download | FFmpeg (HLS + direct) | Direct HTTP | Direct HTTP + yt-dlp |
| Output | MKV (remux, no re-encode) | MKV | MKV (optional FFmpeg) |
| Subtitles | TTML/WebVTT download, converted to SRT, embedded as German track in MKV | Yes | Yes |
| Database | SQLite or PostgreSQL | SQLite | SQLite (Prisma) |
| Web UI | Yes (Vue.js, with setup wizard) | Yes (with setup wizard) | Yes (Next.js, with setup wizard) |
| Port | 6969 | 5007 | 6767 |
| Docker | Multi-arch (amd64, arm64, armv7) | Yes | Multi-arch (amd64, arm64) |
| Auto-config | Yes (creates indexer + download client in Prowlarr/Sonarr/Radarr) | Yes (setup wizard) | No |
| Proxy support | Yes (per-channel network routes with HTTP proxy, for video and subtitle downloads) | Not documented | Yes (for downloads + yt-dlp) |
| Umlaut handling | Built-in | Via UmlautAdaptarr (separate service) | Not specified |
| Match history | Yes (diagnostics + stats, trace per evaluation) | No | No |
| Download schedule | Yes (time windows, HH:mm) | Not documented | Not documented |
| Queue | Persistent, 3 priority levels, pause/resume, retry | Not documented | Not documented |
| Monitoring | Prometheus /metrics (OpenTelemetry), /healthz | Not documented | Not documented |
| UI languages | German (incl. de-AT, de-CH), English | Not documented | Not documented |
| PUID/PGID | Yes | Not documented | Yes |
| ORF/SRF | Via MediathekViewWeb | M3U download (beta.12) | HLS via yt-dlp (SRF needs SRG-SSR credentials) |
MediathekArr
MediathekArr by PCJones is the most popular project in this space (~374 stars). It uses a .NET backend and integrates MediathekViewWeb, UmlautAdaptarr, and TheTVDB.
Strengths
- Largest community with active Discord (UsenetDE server) and Telegram channels - best place to get help if you run into issues
- UmlautAdaptarr (~306 stars) - companion tool that intercepts and modifies search queries between *arr apps and indexers to fix German umlaut matching, title discovery, and release naming across Sonarr, Lidarr, and Readarr (Radarr support in progress)
- Setup wizard in the web interface that guides through initial configuration
- Advanced filter and matching system for TV shows, seasons and episodes
Limitations
- No user-extensible ruleset system - title matching uses built-in logic. Works well for common shows but can't be extended by users for niche content.
- Radarr movie support is limited/WIP. The README states: "You can find a few movies via interactive search, but not a lot."
- ORF and SRF support was added in beta.12 (February 2025) via M3U download. Issue #77 requests disabling ORF by default due to geoblocking.
- Requires UmlautAdaptarr as a separate companion service for proper German title resolution.
- Still in beta - the README warns "use the beta image until 1.0 is released. Latest/Main is not working." Last release (beta.12) is from February 2025. V2 is being planned in issues.
- TVDB only, no TMDB integration.
- SQLite only, database not configurable.
- Downloads via direct HTTP only (no HLS/FFmpeg).
RundfunkArr
RundfunkArr (~40 stars) is a Node.js/Next.js project. Originally also called "MediathekArr", it was renamed to avoid confusion.
Strengths
- yt-dlp integration for HLS stream resolution - handles SRF and ORF streams and supports more edge-case formats than FFmpeg alone. Version pinned with checksum verification in Docker.
- Proxy support for yt-dlp and downloads (not metadata APIs) - useful for accessing geo-restricted content from abroad
- Full Radarr support since v1.1.0 with TMDB/IMDB ID support and intelligent title parsing
- Active development with regular releases, zero open issues, and a setup wizard
- PUID/PGID support and multi-arch Docker images (amd64, arm64)
- Multiple metadata sources: local shows.json → TVDB → TMDB
- Community rulesets with auto-update from GitHub (since v1.2.0)
Limitations
- Rulesets are community-maintained via PRs to the repository - no web UI editor for creating or modifying rules.
- Metadata resolution checks a local
shows.jsonfirst, which needs manual updates for new shows that aren't in TVDB/TMDB. - SRF support requires credentials from the SRG-SSR developer portal.
- yt-dlp resolves video references at download time, not at search time - regional restrictions depend on proxy location and broadcaster availability.
- No scoring, match history or diagnostics.
- Smaller community (~40 stars, no Discord/Telegram).
FunkArr - Honest Limitations
In fairness, FunkArr also has limitations:
- No yt-dlp - uses FFmpeg only for HLS and direct downloads. If a stream format isn't supported by FFmpeg's native HLS demuxer, it fails. yt-dlp handles more edge cases.
- Newest and smallest community - MediathekArr has years of head start and the largest user base. If you need help, there's no Discord or Telegram channel yet.
- TVDB and TMDB API keys required for metadata enrichment - they're optional but needed for full functionality.
- Proxy without automatic fallback - if a configured proxy is unreachable, the download fails. Routes apply to the download pipeline, not to metadata APIs.
- Match history is diagnostic, not adaptive - the scoring engine executes rules deterministically. History records past runs and aggregates stats for debugging, but it doesn't learn or adjust weights based on past results.
When to Use Which
- MediathekArr if you primarily watch ARD/ZDF content and want the largest community for support.
- RundfunkArr if you prefer yt-dlp's broader format handling or want full Radarr movie support.
- FunkArr if you want community-driven rulesets with a visual web editor, match scoring diagnostics, proxy support for geo-restricted content (ORF/SRF), PostgreSQL support, or TMDB metadata alongside TVDB.